Ask the Experts
May 29, 2019
Insufficient Barrel Fill on Through-hole Components
We are having issues with barrel fill. We are using a lead free, no-clean flux process. The issues is with through hole connectors with lead retention mechanisms. Any thoughts?
Expert Panel Responses
Assuming you are hand soldering, you might try a higher wattage soldering iron. Increasing the temperature on a low wattage iron doesn't work well, you will need higher wattage.
A larger tip will also help. If you have tried this, then a hot plate would be the next step. If selective soldering, then a "jet" tip, increased dwell time, and longer preheat should help. We selective solder as much as we can and have good success with it.
Red Lion Controls, Inc.
Tom Schardt has been an Industrial Engineer with Red Lion Controls since 1988 with a degree in Electronics Engineering. He has held the positions of wave solder operator, electronics technician, production assembler, Lead Person and Supervisor. In his current position he is responsible for plant floor design and compliance, implementing new machines and technology, and the selective soldering operation.
The surface finish can have an effect if the assemblies were subjected to one or more prior SMT reflows. Immersion tin can react with copper to create a difficult to wet PTH barrel.
Insufficient flux loading an inadequate pre-heat in the wave process can also inhibit barrel fill. Older boards, subjected to oxidation during storage could also contribute to poor barrel fill.
Global Director of Customer Technical Support
Alpha Assembly Solutions
As the Global Director of Customer Technical Service (CTS) for Alpha, Mitch sets direction and provides coordination for the Alpha CTS group in a global capacity. A major focus of this position is to provide strategic support to OEM, CEM and Automotive customers and target accounts. Mitch joined Alpha in 1998 and has progressed through positions of increasing responsibilities in Marketing, Product Management and R&D. He is a graduate of Purdue University with a degree in Chemistry and holds an MBA from Temple University.
There are several types of lead retention mechanisms. These are design to provide extra support between the lead and the PTH. The ones I've worked with are usually for press-fit connectors which do not require soldering.
The retaining design might block the normal flow of solder in order to meet IPC specifications applied to a non-retained lead. In this case, a pull test might be required to complement the soldered connection. Always contact the component manufacturer or your local rep for additional recommendations.
Senior Manufacturing Engineer
Edithel is a chemical engineer with 20 year experience in manufacturing & process development for electronic contract manufacturers in US as well as some major OEM's. Involved in SMT, Reflow, Wave and other assembly operations entailing conformal coating and robotics.
My experience has identified "Insufficient Barrel Fill" on Through-hole Components can be attributed to the following :
First, have you cross sectioned any PCB samples as received from the vendor/s to verify the thickness of the PCH through hole walls or even if there is any copper in the through hole ? Also, to check for wetting either on the lead or the barrel?
Second, I would revisit your reflow belt speed - compare fast verses slow for time in profile/s. If wave, the check solder bath time and temperature (LF @ 275C pot temp. with 2-3 sec. immersion)and ensure you use a flow accelerator. Typically, immersion times above this will impact most fluxes adversely. More preheat and/or more time on the wave is another area to revisit.
Third, is poor wetting due to oxidation on the leads, oxidation in the barrel, not enough flux, etc. your problem? If you are not using and inert gas atmosphere this may result in oxidation issues and decrease in the barrel fill. The inert gas may increase the wetting of the solder into the barrel and in turn improve your current flux chemistry performance. You can also use a more aggressive flux which will require intensive cleaning post wave.
Fourth, Lead free alloys wet more slowly than do tin led alloys. How thick is your PCB(.093) ? A thicker board exacerbates the problem. There is usually a significant temperature gradient between the bottom of the board and the top side for thicker boards.
Since solder likes heat, the solder is reluctant to flow up the barrel to a cold region. What is your pad finish especially if you are using a tin lead OSP, ENIG, AgImm, etc. Again, you may have to increase the preheat temperature and the time on the wave (again the extent you can do this will depend on the flux).
VP of Advanced Technical Operations
Mark has over 25 years' experience in electronics fabrication, quality and reliability while working for IEC Electronics, GE, Motorola, ORS, etc. He has most recently established IEC Electronics Analysis and Testing Laboratories (IATL), LLC in Albuquerque, NM for electronics and material analysis testing in the military, medical, and industrial industries. His area of expertise includes PCB, PCBA, components, analytical and electrical analysis techniques.
I'll assume that this is a wave soldering process, and not a selective soldering process (though the concerns are similar). Following are some of the things that can contribute to lack of complete barrel fill:
Incomplete fluxing - Lack of sufficient heat transfer because of
The fact that your fill problems seem to be focused on connector leads with retention features tells me that it's most likely that you're not getting sufficient fluxing due to the retention feature blocking the hole. Other factors may be contributing, but if you don't get adequate fluxing up the barrel, wetting can't occur.
- Insufficient heating of leads due to short lead protrusion on the solder side
- Wicking of heat from the barrel due to too many or insufficiently relieved plane connections
- Solderability issues with the leads or barrels
In order to test this theory, select half of the leads with the retention feature on some boards, and carefully apply a *small* droplet of liquid flux (same flux you use in the wave process) to the top side if accessible (bottom side if not). Let the flux wick down or up the hole. Now pass the boards through the normal process. If the added flux eliminates the issue, then blockage of fluxing is the problem.
If this is the problem, it is not an easy one to solve, unless you have selective control of flux application. Just increasing the application generally is not usually a good idea without further study.
Fritz's career in electronics manufacturing has included diverse engineering roles including PWB fabrication, thick film print & fire, SMT and wave/selective solder process engineering, and electronics materials development and marketing. Fritz's educational background is in mechanical engineering with an emphasis on materials science. Design of Experiments (DoE) techniques have been an area of independent study. Fritz has published over a dozen papers at various industry conferences.
Item 88217: poor barrel fill. My assumption is you are wave soldering this board. Here is a list of items to evaluate your process in order to achieve better barrel fill.
Please provide more detail about your process if it is not a wave process.
- Flux deposition do you have full flux coverage on your board?
- Preheat setup. With a thick board you want to monitor the top of the board for the proper topside temperature and heat it from the bottom. If you heat the board from both the top and bottom the middle of the board still may be cold.
- Be careful not to over the board prior to soldering.
- Contact time. With lead free you will need to adjust the conveyor to achieve the proper amount of contact time. This should be 4 - 8 seconds. On a conventional wave solder machine, the contact distance is about 2 inches. Meaning your speed needs to be 2.5 feet / minute or slower.
Sr Fiald Applications Support Engineer
Mr. Kaminsky has 30+ years of circuit board soldering assembly experience along with a patent for wave solder VOC flux process.
- More top side heat
- Higher amount of flux solids to get more flux in the barrel
- Alternative processes: paste and a preform or robotic soldering with flux cored wire
Technical Support Engineer
Kay Parker is a Technical Support Engineer based at Indium Corporation's headquarters in Clinton, N.Y. In this role she provides guidance and recommendations to customers related to process steps, equipment, techniques, and materials. She is also responsible for servicing the company's existing accounts and retaining new business.
There are many variable to achieving barrel fill in through hole technology. Flux activation, preheat time, board thickness ground plane etc.
Without knowing your process such as hand soldering, wave, or selective soldering, I can only suggest you make sure you are using the right amount of flux and proper preheat time to activate the flux and head the board through all layers. You may also need to increase you dwell time if the above does not work for you. Good luck.
Manufacturing Applications Specialist
Mr. Bush has 20 years experience in electronics contract manufacturing. Major areas of expertise include through hole, SMT, wave and selective soldering.
Barrel fill is affected by several things including: the solder alloy and the composition of the alloy, the preheat temperature and time, the solder temperature and contact time, the agitation level in the wave/selective solder, the flux activity and composition, the age of the flux, the penetration level of the flux, the metal finish on the circuit board and component leads, etc.
I suggest the following general steps to improve barrel fill.
- Measure the amount of flux applied by weight, and ensure that it meets the manufacturers recommendation. Increase the amount of flux if necessary.
- Check that the flux penetration is adequate and is reaching the top side of the board. This can be done with paper placed on top of the board and checking for flux spots on the paper over each through hole.
- Check the preheat settings to ensure that the flux is being activated properly per manufacturers recommendation. Do not pre-heat too aggressively or the flux may loose activity before soldering takes place.
- Check the composition of the solder alloy and adjust to meet the recommended specifications if necessary.
- Increase contact time and/or solder temperature to ensure that the top side of the board is reaching the necessary temperature for complete barrel fill. Taking a temperature profile of the top side of the board is the best way to do this.
- Increase the flow rate or agitation rate of the wave/selective solder. This may help the solder to wick properly to the top of the holes.
Tony has worked in the electronics industry since 1994. He worked as a process engineer at a circuit board manufacturer for 5 years. Since 1999, Tony has worked for FCT Companies as a laboratory manager, facility manager, and most recently a field application engineer. He has extensive experience doing research and development, quality control, and technical service with products used to manufacture and assemble printed circuit boards. He holds B.S. and M.B.S. degrees in Chemistry.
In my personal opinion it should not make a difference between Leaded vs ROHS solder, however there are the following number of variables one has to look into at the time of setting up the profile:
Each one of the above variables have an impact on the quality of the overall solderbility of the pin thru hole components.
- Tinning of thru hole connector leads as well as the metallic mass of the components in question
- Thickness of the PCB
- Number of ground planes
- Copper thickness of the foil used
- Preheat temperatures of the wave machine based on the above 4 points
- How well is the flux spray being spread on the board as well as amount of flux getting into the barrels. Maybe in this case a foam flux tray would be better than a sprayer
- How good is the barrel finish at the time of fabrication of the PCB in question
- Amount of impurities and dross in the solder pot
- The hole to the pin aspect ratio
- Adjustments on the "Omega" and "Lamda"
Mahesh V Draksharapu
Over 28 years experience in the area of PCB assembly with 10 years working in various EMS companies in the US (Avex, GSS Array Technology now Benchmark, Everex computer Systems), 10 years working in OEM companies in the US (Trillium Test Systems, Intel & Meru Networks) and with Aristos EMS company in Bangalore since 2008. Engineering Degree from BIT, Mesra and Masters in Egg Mgmt from Wichita State University.
To answer this question there is very little detail you have provided.
- Using FAX paper, cover your load your pcb, place your FAX paper on top, cover with a second PCB, Flux your PCB. Inspect to see if you have any flux penetration.
- Check your hole to lead ratio of it is correct.
- Ensure that you have correct pre heat, and that your flux, is not pre maturely actived before your soldering process.
- Ensure that your dewel time is on the higher end of the spec, 4,5 to 6 seconds contact time.
- You can also look at different Flux types, main Alpha has a wide range for fluxes for improved Bill Fill, in the automotive range of fluxes.
Process Engineering Manager - Electronics
Altech UEC, South Africa
Currently with Altech UEC and responsible for technology road map in PCBA electronic manufacturing and technical support for PCBA electronic manufacturing for Altech UEC and its JDM's. Over 7 years in SMT, Radial Insertion, Wave solder & Test Applications.
You might consider intrusive reflow as opposed to wave soldering. With proper hole to pin ratio and print set up for complete paste hole fill complete barrel fill is possible with lead free solder. Bill Coleman and George Oxx publishes an article on this in SMT several years ago.
Vice President Technology
For over 18 years, Dr. Coleman has been the vice president of technology for Photo Stencil, working closely with customers to understand their printing requirements. His efforts have resulted in several new stencil products.
Plated Through Hole Barrel Fill with lead-free solder and low solid content flux.
Although the thickness of the board and the number of layers is not mentioned, hole filling is based upon getting the board hot enough so the solder will not solidify in the barrel during the soldering operation regardless of the solder alloy being used.
The basic requirement is 75% hole fill for all class 3 products, and for Class 2 the requirement is a bit different depending upon whether or not internallayers are attached to the plated through holes. If the inner layers are in fact connected to the barrel then the requirement is 50% hole fill.
The lead retention is based upon the strength of all the solder joints on the component. Information on the strength of the solder joint can be found in Howard Manko's book, Solders and Soldering and with this information one can calculate the overall attachment strength of the connector itself.
As far as the process is concern, verify good flux coverage up into the plated through hole and if oxidation is found due to the flux not being able to protect the reoxidation of the surface to be soldered then an inert atmosphere can be used, such as nitrogen. Subsequently, the time in the wave has to be calculated to verify the solder has enough time to rise up into the barrel through capillary action.
If the board is thicker than 0.060" then it can be run through the wave at a deeper depth to utilize the hydrostatic pressure of the molten solder to force the solder up into the plated through holes. Keep in mind however that fixtures may be needed to accomplish this methodology as the top side of the board has to be protected from the solder coming over the thickness of the board and allowing solder to short everything on the top side of the board.
Vice President, Technical Director
At EPTAC Corporation, Mr. Lambert oversees content of course offerings, IPC Certification programs and provides customers with expert consultation in electronics manufacturing, including RoHS/WEEE and lead free issues. Leo is also the IPC General Chairman for the Assembly/Joining Process Committee.
There are a number of variables that would need to be addressed to provide specific guidance, but here are some general guidelines. We don't know if this a full wave of selective application, but in either case, higher pot temperatures will improve barrel fill. However, higher temperatures will also increase dross, deplete flux activity and increased risk for PCB thermal damage. If a pallet is in use on a full wave, increasing the wave energy can help with barrel fill.
Low and no silver alloys do not exhibit as robust flow characteristics as SAC305 which can cause barrel fill issues. If the board has not been designed for lead-free processes, the lead-hole ration may need to be adjusted to accommodate the reduced flow of many lead-free alloys. These are just a few considerations. Working with your solder chemistry vendor is key to finding the combination of process/materials that will meet your requirements.
Technical Marketing Manager
Tim O'Neill is the Technical Marketing Manager for AIM Products. AIM is a global supplier of materials for the PCB assembly industry including solders, fluxes and thermal management materials. Tim has a B.A. from Assumption College and post-graduate studies in education. He has 20 years of experience in the electronics soldering industry, beginning his career in 1994 with EFD and was key in business development of their fine pitch solder paste dispensing technology. Tim joined AIM in 1997 and has since assisted many clients with assembly challenges, specializing in Pb-Free process development and material selection.