Ask the Experts
August 3, 2009 - Updated
August 3, 2009 - Originally Posted

Laser spot soldering temperature problem

In the wake of changing an automotive board to lead free, all solder joints have been taken care of except for several selectice solder joints to silver plated contacts. These joints are done using laser spot soldering at a very high local temperatures. Now the SAC solder needs a 30% higher laser energy to reach higher temperatures required for laser spot soldering. How do you suggest we avoid collateral damage to the PCB material and undesired remelting of solder joints in the vicinity when we laser solder these joints? Can you offer any other suggestions?


Expert Panel Responses

SMT is a leading reflowoven supplier, and while we have a well-rounded knowledge of soldering andthermal issues we do not claim enough expertise in the laser soldering field. Therefore,we would like to abstain from commenting on the case presented.

Manfred Maehl
SMT North America, Inc.
Manfred Maehl has been active in the electronics industry for almost 20 years. His latest assignment is the introduction of Europe's leading reflow oven manufacturer SMT, Wertheim to the North American market.

Here are some basic guidelines for laser soldering with Lead Free alloys: It sounds like you are seeing a reflective bounce of the laser beam to other surrounding areas. A higher rated Nm diode laser tends to be more penetrative and less reflective vs a lower rated Nm system. When soldering with an 810 Nm diode more energy is applied onto the pad vs the higher frequencies, however this lower frequency tends to reflect off shinny surfaces more, thus the potential for affecting surrounds components is greater. In contrast, a 980 Nm ~ 1080 Nm diode is more penetrative but often requires a slightly greater power output setting. Since this frequency penetrates the solder/pad more, less actual power is applied to the pad at the same setting of an 810 Nm rating. As a result you will need to increase the laser output to achieve the desired soldering. However at this frequency rating, the beam will not reflect as much, creating a more stable soldering environment. If a thermal plane exists on the circuit to be soldered, we suggest localized hot air assist or pre heating the PCB assembly first. By raising the profile temperature (preheating the area or joint to be soldered) it allows the laser to operate to its maximum potential, reducing cycle rate and.minimizing thermal shock. A few final notes: Most diode laser's solder best with a slightly higher flux content, using special formulated paste or wire for laser soldering. The spot size should match the pad size (when possible) If the system you are using has a fixed focal spot, select the smaller spot size that fits most joints/pads. Over shotting the pad can burn mask and create other issues. Angle of the laser beam is also critical. Most laser soldering manufacturers would suggest pointing the beam at a 1~2 degree angle only.

Gary Goldberg
President and CEO
Mr Goldberg has practical experience in production line layout, process flow and cycle rate analysis. He knows how to avoid bottle necks and most related PCB or pallet handling questions.
Submit A Comment

Comments are reviewed prior to posting. You must include your full name to have your comments posted. We will not post your email address.

Your Name

Your Company
Your E-mail

Your Country
Your Comments

Free Newsletter Subscription
Circuitnet is built for professionals who bear the responsibility of looking ahead, imagining the future, and preparing for it.

Insert Your Email Address