circuitnet
Sponsor
Advanced Interconnections Corp.
Need Improved Solder Joint Visibility?
Solder Peel-A-Way® Removable Terminal Carriers in place and peel the carrier away for complete solder joint visibility on both sides of the PCB. Watch a video to see it in action.
Advanced Interconnections Corp.
Complete Solutions
Sponsor
AI Technology
AIT BUF7669-NP: Diamond-Based Film
• Diamond-based dielectric film for AI chiplets, enabling >8 W/m-K thermal conductivity substrates; • Stress-absorbing polymer with 18 ppm/°C CTE; • Made in USA; ABF alternative
AI Technology
Ask the Experts
QUESTIONS
  
MEMBERS
November 26, 2012 - Updated
November 13, 2012 - Originally Posted

Solder Joint Strength

Which surface finish provides the best solder joint bond strength for a leaded assembly, HASL or ENIG? Is there enough of a difference in strength to make either a better choice for a high-vibration military application?
E.H.
Expert Panel Responses
Whensoldering to ENIG, you are bonding to a nickel surface and forming a nickel-tinintermetallic. With HASL, the intermetallic is formed to a copper surfaceresulting in a copper-tin intermetallic. The copper-tin intermetallic istypically more robust than the nickel-tin intermetallic. Therefore, froma solder bond perspective, you would expect to have a more reliable solderjoint on the HASL surface. However, there are many other things toconsider. For example, the planarity of the HASL surface is not as goodas ENIG. That can result in poorer printed paste transferefficiency. A bad print can more than offset any gain achieved by theimproved intermetallic bond.

Tim Jensen
Tim Jensen
Product Manager, Advanced Assembly Materials, Indium Corp.
Timothy Jensen is the Product Manager for Indium Corporation's PCB Assembly Materials and has spent over a decade troubleshooting and optimizing SMT process lines. Having worked directly on hundreds of surface mount lines, and building thousands of different products, Tim understands each customer's unique requirements, and tailors Indium's products and services to meet or exceed those needs.
Submit A Comment
Comments are reviewed prior to posting. You must include your full name to have your comments posted. We will not post your email address.

Your Name


Your Company
Your E-mail


Your Country
Your Comments



Free Newsletter Subscription
Circuitnet is built for professionals who bear the responsibility of looking ahead, imagining the future, and preparing for it.

Insert Your Email Address

Sponsor
Plasma Etch
High power atmospheric plasma system
Our 1000 Atmospheric Plasma System is available with PC or PLC control for lab or high speed production use with the same high powered systems. Remove contaminants and increase bond strength!
Plasma Etch
Low-Silver Solder Alternatives