|Ask the Experts|
February 27, 2018
What Causes Solder Fillet Peaks?
We have a PCB which is held in place with a 2mm screw. This screw head is soldered to a large pad on the PCB surface by a single point solder robot. The problem is that the robot soldering iron leaves a small peak formed in the solder joint. We have tried adjusting dwell times and temperatures but nothing appears to consistently improve the situation. Can you offer advice on what may cause this defect and how to eliminate it?
|Expert Panel Responses|
Solder spikes are usually a function of flux performance and/or joint temperature dynamic. If the flux is fully expended, oxide forms on the molten solder surface, fostering spikes. If there is sufficient heat sinking, the alloy will be continually cooled, increasing the probability of a spike when the iron is withdrawn. I recommend experimenting with two options: 1) a preheat before wire feed and 2) solder paste. The preheat before wire feed may preserve enough flux to avoid the spikes. Solder paste has a very low probability of spike creation because it has more flux to begin with, and that flux is designed to remain effective longer than the flux in wire core.
Application Engineering Supervisor
Solder peaks are usually caused by a few reasons such as; not enough flux, the solder iron is pulled away from the solder joint in a perpendicular direction or the iron is not hot enough to allow the solder to spread over the component surfaces.
Vice President, Technical Director
There are a few things you could try to eliminate the peak. Vary the direction of wipe off to encourage the solder to pull back into the bulk of the solder. Increase the contact time and/or temperature to ensure the screw head is fully above the solder melting point and the solder is not "chilling". Apply some liquid flux prior to soldering - the flux will help the solder peak to fall back into the bulk. Alternatively, if you are using cored solder, try a different type of flux with perhaps increased activity. A large solder bit size may also help since it will reduce the potential "chilling" effect of the screw mass.
Principal Engineer - CMA Lab
I would test a higher percentage flux content solder wire first
Technical Sales Manager
BLT Circuit Services Ltd
It is possible that the robotic soldering device is focusing the heat in a very localized point. Since solder tends to follow heat, the last point of the solder joint to cool will have a slight peak. The thickness of the solder joint between the soldered surfaces is the most important factor for reliability. It seems from the description that the defect may be more cosmetic than functional, but it is difficult to be completely sure without seeing the solder result. Physically removing the solder arm from the solder very quickly may reduce the magnitude of the defect.
Global Product Manager
The peak is formed from the solder turning solidus as the tip is being removed. This indicates that the components are sinking the heat from the joint (insufficient heating), or the tip is being raised too quickly. Try using a larger tip, increasing the dwell time, or both. You may need to preheat the screw before soldering. The issue of flux consumption also produces solder spikes. Solder re-oxidizes when heated and insufficient fluxing action can result in an oxide shell that increases the probability of a solder spike. This would require a reduction in dwell time, or an increased amount of flux to correct.
M.O.L.E. Line Product Manager
Electronic Controls Design, Inc. (ECD)
If the solder is flowing properly it is unlikely that it is caused by the temperature of the soldering iron. The peaks are a result of the flux characteristics of the wire. A low solids flux will cause the solder to reoxidize and leave an oxide film resulting in the peak. A higher solids content flux would resolve the issue.
Deck Street Consultants
Why are you soldering the screw in the first place? Wouldn't a SEMS type screw embed itself into the solder pad and create the same good mechanical reliability.
Applications Project Manager
Quick Turn Flex Circuits LLC
Without seeing a picture, I can't say for sure, but it does not sound like a defect, unless it ends up causing field failures. One thought would be to heat the screw pad with the solder tip, and feed the wire from the other side after a small preheat time with the iron tip. This can draw solder around the screw, and minimize the amount that is actually in contact with the iron tip. This may take too long to heat up the screw/pad, but it might be something to look at.
Manager Advanced Development
|Submit A Comment|
Free Newsletter Subscription
Circuitnet is built for professionals who bear the responsibility of looking ahead, imagining the future, and preparing for it.
Insert Your Email Address